请问2001年的Skyline 300GT，Toyota Windom和2003年的Honda Accord v6哪个最好啊

baikal

请问2001年的Nissan Skyline V35 300GT，Toyota Windom （Lexus ES300）和2003年的Honda Accord v6（NZ New）哪个最好啊？
都是3.0 V6的发动机。市场定位好像也差不多。价格也差不太多。
请大家说说看法，谢谢。

发动机信息：

Honda：
J30A
The J30A displaces 2,997 cc (2.997 L; 182.9 cu in) and is a SOHC VTEC design. Output for the light weight 250 lb (110 kg) J30A1 was 200 hp (150 kW) @ 5500 RPM and 195 lb·ft (264 N·m) of torque @ 4700 RPM. The J30A4 pushed output to 240 hp (180 kW) and 212 lb·ft (287 N·m) using a three-way VTEC system, higher (10:1) compression ratio, and a novel exhaust manifold cast as one piece with the cylinder head. It weighs nearly 20 lb (9.1 kg) less and is an inch shorter than J30A1. This version was on the Ward's 10 Best Engines list for 2003 and 2004.
J30A4

• 2003-2005 Honda Accord V6

J30A5

• 2006-2007 Honda Accord V6
• Variable Cylinder Management
• 2003-2007 Honda Inspire

Nissan：
VQ30DD
The 2987cc engine has Bore and stroke of 93 mm and 73.3 mm, with a compression ratio of 11.0:1. It produces 230 PS (170 kW; 230 hp) to 260 PS (190 kW; 260 hp) @6400 rpm and 217 to 239 ft·lbf (294 to 324 N·m) @3600 rpm.
It is fitted to the following vehicles:

• 1997–1999 Nissan Leopard Y33 230 PS (170 kW; 230 hp) and 217 ft·lbf (294 N·m)
• 1999–2004 Nissan Cedric Y34
• 1999–2004 Nissan Gloria Y34 240 PS (180 kW; 240 hp) and 228 ft·lbf (309 N·m)
• 2001–2004 Nissan Skyline V35
• 2001–2004 Nissan Stagea M35 260 PS (190 kW; 260 hp) and 239 ft·lbf (324 N·m)

Toyota：
The 1MZ-FE is a 3.0 L (2994 cc) engine. Bore is 87.5 mm and stroke is 83 mm. Output is 168–190 hp @ 5200–5400 rpm with 183–193 ft·lbf of torque at 4400 rpm. Horsepower ratings dropped after the Society of Automotive Engineers implemented a new power measurement system for vehicle engines, Toyota engines rated on 87 octane dropped the most, compared to the same engines used by Lexus rated on 91 octane. It has bucket tappets and was designed for good fuel economy without an overall performance trade-off.
The 1MZ-FE was on Ward's 10 Best Engines list for 1996.
Applications:

• 1994–2006 Toyota Camry (V6)
• 1994–2003 Lexus ES 300 & Toyota Windom (Japanese domestic market)
• 1995–2004 Toyota Avalon & 2000 Toyota Pronard (Avalon for Japanese domestic market)
• 1998–2000 Toyota Sienna
• 1999–2003 Toyota Solara (V6)
• 2000– Toyota Estima (Japanese domestic market)

GRMVT

三大日本车商的产品，品质上基本没什么问题，外形看个人喜好， 就技术数据而言

SKYLINE 300GT 是FR后驱，其他两个是FF前驱，
就马力大小排序: SKYLINE 300GT > Accord v6 >  Windom 3.0
就车体重量排序: Windom 3.0 > Accord v6 > SKYLINE 300GT
就厂家油耗排序: Windom 3.0 （9.8km/L) >  SKYLINE 300GT (11.6km/L) > = Accord v6 (11.6km/L) ( Accord v6使用的是普通无铅,其他两种是高级无铅)
就车身尺寸排序: Windom 3.0 > SKYLINE 300GT > Accord v6  
就车内空间排序: Windom 3.0 > Accord v6 > SKYLINE 300GT


就个人喜好而言，排序是300GT, Toyota Windom,  Accord v6,
如果条件允许，最好都试驾体验一下，每个人的自身感觉是不同的，好的标准也是因人而异。

baikal

谢谢你，分析的真不错

baikal

顶一下………………

aklppt

市场定位差太多了  300GT是性能/品质房车   剩下那2个是经济型买菜车

跟Skyline系列完全对位竞争的日系里面大概只有 Toyota MarkX     

Legacy也可以算

baikal

那么说300GT比较好了

silver

其他两个有的300gt有，300gt 有的其他两个没有。

baikal

今天试了一下300GT，发现避震有点过软了

tangren

三大日本车商的产品，品质上基本没什么问题，外形看个人喜好， 就技术数据而言

SKYLINE 300GT 是FR后驱，其他两个是FF前驱，
就马力大小排序: SKYLINE 300GT > Accord v6 >  Windom 3.0
就车体重量排序: Windo ...
GRMVT 发表于 2011-2-17 14:47

太专业了!!!

cooper_zx

300GT  个人喜好

Calvin_Chan

個人喜歡300GT > WINDOM > ACCORD

目前家中有臺WINDOM~ 97年的~ 很皮實~ 很不錯~

flyinbed

感覺WINDOM的質量要好多其他兩個....