[育儿话题]奥克兰学校教育质量之比较：一个定量分析

z-score

首先我需要向大家道歉，一周之后的时间我才发出帖子。发这个贴子的目的主要是想比较一下奥克兰公立学校和私立学校对于孩子的教学质量有没有差别．我想这个板块的爸爸妈妈都会望子成龙，望女成凤．在我的分析里，衡量教学质量的指标是高考成绩入大学的升学率。

首先，先来解释一些术语。

Decile – 是一个从1 – 10的指数，是一个学校学生家长的收入指标。如果一个学校的decile是10, 这代表学生家长的平均收入是在新西兰所有人的收入中占最高的10%.Decile 1就是收入最低的10%. Decile 99在这个分析里面代表私立学校。

NCEA – (National Certificate of Educational Achievement) 是新西兰的高中National Qualification. 新西兰大部分的学生是以这个考试途径试图进入大学的。

CIE – (Cambridge International Examinations) 是英国剑桥大学起源设计给在国外的英国人进入英国大学的考试系统。CIE现在在全球数多国家被推广。新西兰有少些学校采用CIE.

阅读之前的一些注意事项:
在我的分析中，我只去看了学校用NCEA进入大学的方式，因为我没有CIE的数据。有很多只提供CIE的学校升学率也很高，但是我在我的分析中没有考虑到这些学校。

认识我的朋友们不用担心，我没有挪用任何公家的数据，不会造成任何隐私的问题。放心的看吧。

首先咱们先看一下decile对高中升学率有没有影响。我用统计软件R画出以下的图。



大家如图所看，当decile增加的时候，学校的升学率基本上也会增加。这说明，decile越高的学校，学生总体水平越高。

以下是奥克兰地区的高中入大学的升学率的具体数字。我所计算的升学率(UE)是看学校的NCEA升学率。升学率计算方式是由学校进入大学总人数除以学过至少一门高考科目的总人数。

School	Decile	UE
St. Cuthbert's College	99	0.97
Diocesan School for Girls	99	0.95
Carmel College	10	0.91
Saint Kentigern College	99	0.86
Saint Mary's College	5	0.82
Baradene College of the Sacred Heart	10	0.8
Dilworth School	5	0.78
Takapuna Grammar	10	0.77
Epsom Girls' Grammar School	10	0.77
Glendowie College	9	0.75
Kingsway School	10	0.74
Rosmini College	10	0.73
Marist College	6	0.73
Western Springs College	7	0.73
Kristin School	10	0.73
Rangitoto College	10	0.72
Hato Petera College	3	0.7
Pakuranga College	9	0.7
Westlake Girls' High School***	10	0.7
Sacred Heart College	8	0.69
Elim Christian College	9	0.69
Mahurangi College	7	0.68
Waiuku College	7	0.67
Zayed College for Girls	4	0.64
Pukekohe High School	6	0.63
Long Bay College	10	0.6
Macleans College***	10	0.59
Howick College	10	0.59
Saint Dominic's College	6	0.59
Birkenhead College	6	0.59
Michael Park School	9	0.58
Northcote College	9	0.57
Mount Roskill Grammar School	4	0.57
Lynfield College	7	0.55
Westlake Boys' High School***	10	0.55
Auckland Grammar School***	10	0.54
Waiheke High School	4	0.54
Liston College	6	0.54
Thames High School	7	0.53
Rosehill College	7	0.52
Wentworth College	99	0.5
Mount Albert Grammar School	5	0.49
Orewa College	8	0.49
Avondale College	5	0.46
Massey High School	6	0.46
Tuakau College	3	0.45
Auckland Girls' Grammar School	5	0.43
Glenfield College	8	0.42
Green Bay High School	7	0.41
Edgewater College	4	0.41
Rutherford College	5	0.4
Selwyn College	5	0.39
Kelston Girls' College	4	0.38
King's College***	99	0.37
Onehunga High School	3	0.36
Marcellin College	3	0.35
Tangaroa College	1	0.35
Kelston Boys' High School	4	0.32
The Manurewa High School	3	0.31
Wesley College	2	0.31
Auckland Seventh-Day Adventist High School	2	0.3
Papatoetoe High School	4	0.3
Saint Peter's College***	7	0.29
Penrose High School	3	0.28
Henderson High School	3	0.27
McAuley High School	1	0.26
Sir Edmund Hillary Collegiate	1	0.25
Papakura High School	2	0.24
Waitakere College	4	0.24
Southern Cross Campus	1	0.23
Aorere College	2	0.18
Otahuhu College	1	0.18
De La Salle College	1	0.17
Corran School***	10	0.17
James Cook High School	2	0.15
Tamaki College	1	0.14
Mangere College	1	0.13
Saint Paul's College	3	0.04
Al-Madinah School	2	0

注意: *** 代表这个学校既提供NCEA也提供CIE.一般这种学校会把他们认为聪明的学生放到CIE的班里，把他们认为不聪明的学生放到NCEA班里。这些有***的学校都是名声很棒的学校，但是我想让大家注意到的是，如果学生在这些学校被分到NCEA班里，似乎学生能上大学的几率似乎和其他普通学校一样，甚至更低。

上面的图片decile 10包括decile 99的私立学校。

[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-30 15:15 编辑 ]

z-score

从开始的图片看出来decile 10的学校平均表现最好。以下是奥克兰所有的decile 10小学和高中。

Albany  Junior High School	Appleby Road	Albany
Albany School	6 Bass Road	Albany
Alfriston  School	Cnr Mill &  Alfriston Roads
Auckland  Grammar	Mountain Road	Epsom
Auckland  Normal Intermediate	Poronui Street	Mt.Eden
Baradene  College	237 Victoria Avenue	Remuera
Baverstock  Oaks School	Baverstock Road	Flat Bush
Bayfield  School	2 12 Clifton Road	Herne Bay
Belmont  Intermediate	10 Winscombe Street	Belmont
Botany Downs  Secondary College	575 Chapel Road	Howick
Browns Bay  School	Masterton Road	Browns Bay
Bucklands  Beach Intermediate	247 Bucklands Beach  Road	Bucklands Beach
Bucklands  Beach Primary School	107 Clovelly Road	Bucklands Beach
Campbells Bay  School	77 Aberdeen Road	Castor Bay
Carmel  College	108 Shakespeare Road	Milford
Chelsea  School	Onetaunga Road	Birkenhead
Churchill  Park School	Riddell Road	Glendowie
Clevedon  School	13 North Road	Clevedon
Coatesville  School	Mahoenui Valley Road	Albany
Cockle Bay  School	Sandspit Road	Howick
Dairy Flat  School	State Highway 17	Dairy Flat
Devonport  School	Kerr Street	Devonport
Epsom Girls'  Grammar School	Silver Road	Epsom
Epsom Normal  School	41 The Drive	Epsom
Ficino School	27 Esplanade Road	Mt Eden
Glamorgan  School	Glamorgan Drive	Torbay
Greenhithe  School	Isobel Road	Greenhithe
Hauraki  School	Jutland Road	Takapuna
Hobsonville  School	Hobsonville Road
Howick  College	Sandspit Road	Howick
Kadimah  College	108 Greys Avenue	Newton
Kings College	Golf Avenue	Otahuhu
Kings School  (Remuera)	258 Remuera Road	Remuera
Kingsway  School	100 Jelas Road
Kohia Terrace  School	3 Kohia Terrace	Epsom
Kohimarama  School	112 Kohimarama Road	Kohimarama
Kristin  School	360 Albany Highway	Albany
Long Bay  College	Ashley Avenue	Torbay
Long Bay  School	Ralph Eagles Place	Torbay
Macleans  College	Macleans Road	Bucklands Beach
Mairangi Bay  School	Agathis Avenue	Mairangi Bay
Marina View  School	97-99 Marina View  Drive	West Harbour
Maungawhau  School	Ellerton Road	Mt.Eden
Meadowbank  School	Waiatarua Road	Remuera
Mellons Bay  School	140 Mellons Bay Road	Howick
Milford  School (Auckland)	34 Shakespeare Road	Milford
Murrays Bay  Intermediate	Sunrise Avenue	Murrays Bay
Murrays Bay  School	Clematis Avenue	Murrays Bay
Northcross  Intermediate	10 Sartors Avenue	Browns Bay
Oteha Valley  School	Medallion Drive	Albany
Our Lady  Sacred Heart School (Epsom)	19 Banff Avenue	Epsom
Parnell  School	St Stephens Avenue	Parnell
Pigeon  Mountain School	22 Wells Road	Bucklands Beach
Pinehill  School	Hugh Green Dr	Browns Bay
Ponsonby  Primary School	44 Curran Street	Herne Bay
Rangitoto  College	564 East Coast Road	Browns Bay
Remuera  School	25-33 Dromorne Road	Remuera
Ridgeview  School	Cutts Crescent	Paremoremo
Rosmini  College	36 Dominion Street	Takapuna
Shelly Park  School	Sunnyviews Avenue	Howick
Sherwood  School (Auckland)	Sartors Avenue	Browns Bay
Somerville  Intermediate School	39 Somerville Road	Howick
St Ignatius  School (St Heliers)	72 Speight Road	St Heliers
St John's  School (Mairangi Bay)	87 a Penzance Road	Mairangi Bay
St Kentigern  Primary School (Remuera)	82 Shore Road	Remuera
St Leos  School (Devonport)	4 Owens Road	Devonport
St Michael's  School (Remuera)	6 Beatrice Road	Remuera
Stanley Bay  School	15 Russell Street	Devonport
Star of the  Sea School (Howick)	14 Oakridge Way	Howick
Sunny Hills  School	17 The Crest	Pakuranga
Takapuna  Grammar School	210 Lake Road	Takapuna
Takapuna  Normal Intermediate	54 b Taharoto Road	Takapuna
Taupaki  School	Cottle Road	Henderson R D 2
Te Hihi  School	Linwood Road	Papakura
The Corelli  School	50 Anzac Road	Browns Bay
Titirangi  School	Atkinson Road	Titirangi
Torbay School	Deep Creek Road	Torbay
Upper Harbour  Primary School	140 Kyle Road	Albany
Vauxhall  School	Morrison Avenue	Devonport
Victoria  Avenue School	282 Victoria Avenue	Remuera
Waitoki  School	1119 Kahikatea Flat  Road	Waitoki
Westlake  Boys' High School	Forrest Hill Road	Takapuna
Westlake  Girls' High School	2 Wairau Road	Takapuna
Westminster  Christian School	31 Westminster  Gardens	Glenfield
Whenuapai  School	14 Airport Road	Whenuapai
Willowbank  School (Howick)	56 Middlefield Drive	Howick

新西兰现在的教育体制对于新生入校还是保持着school zone校区的政策。进入decile 高校区的房价又是多少呢? 以下是我用今年奥克兰房屋交易的数据分析的一些地区房屋中间价。

Remuera      907500
Epsom          800000
Ponsonby     787500
Greenlane    620000
Mt. Roskill    490000


我个人不是很了解房地产，如果上面的数据分析错了，希望大家懂房地产的帮助我纠正。



[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-24 22:14 编辑 ]

z-score

如果房价都这么贵，是不是还不如买个便宜点的房子来投资，送孩子去上私立学校。我们来看一看这些有名的私立学校的学费。


King’s School小学的学费表。

  

2007 Fees
Tuition		Per Term	Per Annum
Junior School	Y1 - Y3	2,600.00	10,400.00
Middle School	Y4 - Y6	2,790.00	11,160.00
Senior School	Y7 - Y8	2,995.00	11,980.00
Compulsory Levies
Development Fund	All pupils	250.00	1000.00
Old Boys Sub	Y7 - Y8	33.75	135.00
Friends Sub	One off payment		100.00
Sports	Y4 upwards only	20.00	80.00
Registration Fee
All pupils	One off payment		225.00
Entrance Fee
All pupils	One off payment		1000.00
Disbursements
Covers such items as text books, camping   and field trips, stationery, photocopying etc.	Paid at beginning   of the following term	*160.00	*640.00
Clothing
Initial outfitting of pupil.	Junior pupil		*1000.00
	Middle/Senior pupil		*1300.00

St. Cuthbert’s College的学费表。

Tuition and Boarding Feesfor 2007

  

Tuition (per term)
Year  1 - Year 6	$2,997.00
Year  7 - Year 10	$3,498.00
Year 11 - Year 13	$3,555.00
Boarding (per term)	$2,552.00

International Students

  

Tuition (per term)
Year 1 - Year 6	$5,994.00
Year 7 - Year 10	$6,996.00
Year 11 - Year 13	$7,110.00
Boarding (per term)	$2,552.00

Diocesan School for Girls的学费表。

Registration Fee
All applications require NZ$112.50 registration fee.This fee is not refundable.
Enrolment Fee
An enrolment fee isrequired as confirmation of acceptance of any place offered (Anglican clergy50% of fee that applies). This amount is an additional separate fee and is notoffset against tuition fees. This fee is not refundable.

Fees are:
Year 1 - Year 6	(New  Entrants - Standard 4)	NZ$1,125.00
Year 7 - Year  10	(Form  1 - Form 4)	NZ$843.75
Year 11 - Year 13	(Form 5 -  Form 7)	NZ$562.50
International		NZ$1,125.00

Tuition Fees
Junior SchoolYear1 - Year 6 NZ$12,287.00 per annum NZ$3,071.75 per quarter
SecondarySchool
Year 7 - Year 13 NZ$14,256.00 per annum NZ$3,564.00 per quarter
Additional costs are charged quarterly for incidental items e.g. stationery,class trips, photographs, laptop costs, sports activities, outdoor education,specialist subject costs, subscription to Old Girls' League and Parents &Friends’ Associations.
International Students Fees
Year 9 - Year 13NZ$24,010.00 per annum
The International Students Fee includes any incidental costs incurred by thestudent during the year. It does not include the costs of private speech ormusic tuition nor uniform items which must be paid for separately.International Students Fees are payable in full prior to the commencement ofthe school year and are non-refundable in the event of the early withdrawal ofthe student.

ACG Senior College的学费表

Registration Fee
No fee is required to register an application.

Enrolment Fee
New ZealandResidents and Citizens
An enrolment fee of $400 is payable to reserve any place offered.

International Students
No enrolment fee is required as this is included in the tuition fee payment.
A registration fee of $200 is payable once only.

New Zealand Residents andCitizens
2008 payment options for tuition fees at ACG Senior College:

Annual Fee 2008
If  paid in full by 1st Feb 2008 pay only (5.5% discount)	$13,640.00
Three Instalments   Due on 1st Feb; 1st May and 1st  Aug 2008	$ 4,664.00
Annaul  payment (3.0% discount)	$ 13,992.00
Nine Monthly Instalments   Due on 1st Feb; 1st March; 1st April; 1st  May; 1st June; 1st July; 1st August; 1st  Sep and 1st Oct 2008	$ 1,603.00
Annaul  payment	$14,427.00

King’s College的学费

New  Zealand citizens and permanent residents
Per Term Per Annum
Years 9, 10 & 11 Tuition $4,297 $17,188
Years 12 & 13 Tuition $4,469 $17,876
WEEKLY BOARDING
Boarding Fee $2,516 $10,064
Years 9, 10 & 11 incl Tuition $6,813 $27,252
Years 12 & 13 incl Tuition $6,985 $27,940
FULL BOARDING
Boarding Fee $2,833 $11,332
Years 9, 10 & 11 incl Tuition $7,130 $28,520
Years 12 & 13 incl Tuition $7,302 $29,208

如果大家对我一上的分析有疑问或争议，我保留了所有的数据，可以随时给大家发过去检查。

[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-20 20:44 编辑 ]

z-score

贴子里面的错别字肯定很多．原谅一下．

[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-16 15:22 编辑 ]

BuyQueen

THX SOOOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!

Truly useful information..........

猪尾巴他老妈

啊，终于等来这个帖子了，先谢谢lz了，我仔细慢慢看。

prayer914

UE 指的是什么？？

z-score

原帖由 prayer914 于 2007-10-16 18:17 发表
UE 指的是什么？？

可算找到电脑了. 我回来修改一下, UE指的是University Entrance，就是高考获得大学入学标准. 是不是那个图片你们都看不到啊？

[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-16 18:54 编辑 ]

z-score

原帖由 z-score 于 2007-10-16 18:51 发表


可算找到电脑了. 我回来修改一下, UE指的是University Entrance，就是高考获得大学入学标准. 是不是那个图片你们都看不到啊？

好了，图应该能看到了吧？

z-score

原帖由 BuyQueen 于 2007-10-16 16:04 发表
THX SOOOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!

Truly useful information..........

你真适合做侦探，我在这里发的帖子你都看到了，真能潜水。

z-score

原帖由 猪尾巴他老妈 于 2007-10-16 17:37 发表
啊，终于等来这个帖子了，先谢谢lz了，我仔细慢慢看。

恩，不好意思，说了这么长时间我才写出来。

z-score

原帖由 zoesong2001 于 2007-10-16 19:03 发表
Good info..
Strange, when I first looked at it, all the good schools, Takapuna Grammar, intermdiate and Rosmini College are around the block where I live. and Westlake Girls  is not far away. Wh ...

呵呵，北岸那里确实区域环境和学校质量都很好。阿童木没做任何recommendation因为觉得这样大家能做好对自己的选择。

prayer914

为什么图上的点比后面表格里面的学校多呢？

[ 本帖最后由 prayer914 于 2007-10-16 21:24 编辑 ]

clam

我的母校排名很高哦。。。。哈哈哈哈

snowhite

阿童木和CLAM也光顾这里呀

[ 本帖最后由 snowhite 于 2007-10-16 21:40 编辑 ]

z-score

原帖由 prayer914 于 2007-10-16 21:22 发表
为什么图上的点比后面表格里面的学校多呢？

哇，太佩服版主了，差4个都看出来了。图里面没有那几个***的学校，因为这些学校的decile很高，但是NCEA的升学率并不体现真正的学校实力。我到楼帖补充一下，谢谢。

z-score

原帖由 snowhite 于 2007-10-16 21:32 发表
阿童木和CLAM也光顾这里呀

恩，我准备以后在这里多发关于教育的帖子，不过不知道大家都有什么需求，需要了解那些教育的事项。

clam

Cambridge的exam好像國際性的認可度較高

z-score

原帖由 clam 于 2007-10-16 21:46 发表
Cambridge的exam好像國際性的認可度較高

这个是一个很热门的话题。NCEA与CIE的比较。很多高中的校长们为了这个都打起来了。

CIE是一个比NCEA要难很多的考试系统，但是对学生好坏现在还看不出来。

读CIE的学生确实可以申请英国大学。不过英国教育部现在已经ban CIE了，说那是一个给国外学生的文凭。

如果大家想更了解NCEA和CIE的差别，我可以再写一篇NCEA与CIE的比较，解释一下系统结构，怎样选课，和选什么课对上大学最好。不过可能这个板块的妈妈们都很年轻，宝宝们还没这么大。

prayer914

LS说得对， 等孩子那么大的时候，了这里又会改了。。。。

想当年， 我考的是BURSARY呢。。。

clam

原帖由 prayer914 于 2007-10-16 22:07 发表
LS说得对， 等孩子那么大的时候，了这里又会改了。。。。

想当年， 我考的是BURSARY呢。。。

me too~~~~~

z-score

原帖由 prayer914 于 2007-10-16 22:07 发表
LS说得对， 等孩子那么大的时候，了这里又会改了。。。。

想当年， 我考的是BURSARY呢。。。

当年觉得Bursary好难啊，现在觉得NCEA里面什么难题都没有。

z-score

更新decile 10学校的地址了．

ANSON7

Rangitoto College
     9
     0.72
   ?????????????????
please double check with the decile! You put that in the other talbe is 10 with the address.
Also, that  is 10 in the ERO report. (www.ero.govt.nz)

[ 本帖最后由 ANSON7 于 2007-10-17 12:00 编辑 ]

z-score

原帖由 ANSON7 于 2007-10-17 11:23 发表
Rangitoto College
     9
     0.72
   ?????????????????
please double check with the decile! You put that in the other talbe is 10 with the address.
Also, I  that  is 10 in the ERO report. ( ...

谢谢lsd, 输入错误．Rangitoto确实是decile 10的，没错．ERO的report就不用看了．

lsd好激动阿，什么叫做"Also, I that is 10 in the ERO report"?, I read that it is 10? 应该是吧．

[ 本帖最后由 z-score 于 2007-10-17 11:34 编辑 ]

ANSON7

原帖由 z-score 于 2007-10-17 11:28 发表


谢谢lsd, 输入错误．Rangitoto确实是decile 10的，没错．ERO的report就不用看了．

lsd好激动阿，什么叫做"Also, I that is 10 in the ERO report"?, I read that it is 10? 应该是吧．

typing erro, in a hurry, sorry.

z-score

原帖由 ANSON7 于 2007-10-17 12:00 发表

typing erro, in a hurry, sorry.

哈哈，看懂了，谢谢lsd.

ANSON7

原帖由 z-score 于 2007-10-16 21:58 发表


这个是一个很热门的话题。NCEA与CIE的比较。很多高中的校长们为了这个都打起来了。

CIE是一个比NCEA要难很多的考试系统，但是对学生好坏现在还看不出来。

读CIE的学生确实可以申请英国大学。不过英国 ...

强烈要求！！！！

z-score

原帖由 ANSON7 于 2007-10-17 12:26 发表

强烈要求！！！！

真的吗？我以为我写关于教育的题目都很无聊呢。那我写一个NCEA与CIE只比较？写好了发到那个板块啊？